The Family of Robert Dotson Announce Plans to Sue City Over Shooting

Thursday, April 20, 2023 at 9:49 PM

Robert "Robbie" and Kim Dotson (Courtesy Facebook)

Attorney Shon Northam says he will make a request for San Juan District Attorney Robert Tedrow and New Mexico Attorney General Raul Torrez to bring criminal charges of 2nd Degree Murder against the officers involved in the case. A second attorney hired by the family, Mark Reichel, is requesting the United States Attorney for the District of New Mexico to bring federal charges against the officers involved for federal civil rights violations.

At a press conference Thursday, Dotson family attorney Shon Northam announced plans to sue the city over the officer-involved shooting on April 5, 2023 that resulted in the death of Robert "Robbie" Dotson at his home at 5305 Valley View in Farmington. The address is significant because officers were called to 5308 Valley View for a reported case of domestic violence, but responded to the Dotson address. The ensuing incident is currently under investigation by New Mexico State Police and the three Farmington Police Officers involved have been placed on administrative leave. The officers have yet to be identified by Farmingtion Police.

Today, Northam pointed out sections of the officer's bodycam footage that seems to show they knew they were at the wrong address before the shooting took place. He alleges this latest incident is part of a pattern: "For quite some time the residents of Farmington have been keenly aware of the wild use of force by the Farmington Police Department, with no accountability or justice provided for the victims. We demand that changes. We want what happened to Robbie to also result in a better community for everyone in Farmington,” said attorney Shon Northam. The legal team will discuss their investigation and plans for a lawsuit for damages against all responsible for this tragedy. Also, “We are calling for the resignation of the Police Chief based on the obvious malfeasance in running the department. We also demand the City Council investigate the extensive amount of excessive force claims against the Police Department, and in fact, corruption within the department to cover up their constant malfeasance,” said Northam.

Northam says he will make a request for San Juan District Attorney Robert Tedrow and New Mexico Attorney General Raul Torrez to bring criminal charges of 2nd Degree Murder against the officers involved in the case. A second attorney hired by the family, Mark Reichel, is requesting the United States Attorney for the District of New Mexico to bring federal charges against the officers involved for federal civil rights violations.

Both attorneys for the Dotson family are from northern California.

Farmington Police Department related this statement "The Farmington Police Department wants to emphasize that the events of April 5 are part of an ongoing investigation. Our department is committed to cooperating with the New Mexico State Police for a thorough and fair investigation into the circumstances surrounding Mr. Dotson’s death. It is important to let the legal process take its course and not draw conclusions before all the facts are known. We will continue to cooperate with the appropriate agencies and provide updates to the public as the investigation progresses. We will continue to work with transparency and integrity."

The press release from the Dotson family's legal team is attached below:

More from Local News

One Dead After House Fire Saturday Afternoon

Second occupant in critical condition; Identity of victims not yet released.
First Native American President Named at Fort Lewis College

As Vice President of Diversity Affairs at FLC, Heather Shotton has played a pivotal role in advancing a culture of belonging and enhancing student access and success. In addition to her work in diversity affairs, she serves as Acting Dean of Student Engagement, overseeing more than 70 staff members supporting student well-being and success.
Arrest Made after Durango Rec Center Damaged by Gunfire

The initial call was received at 5:23 AM. The individual was identified from video surveillance. The male was contacted by Durango Police Department Patrol and is now in custody. He has been identified as Joe Brinkerhoff, a resident of the City of Durango. Due to a prior incident, Joe Brinkerhoff was trespassed from the property and his Rec Center privileges were suspended.
Police Arrest Woman for Husband's Fatal Stabbing 5 years ago

After a thorough and ongoing investigation by detectives and working with the district attorney's office, a thorough review of the case was conducted, and the decision to proceed with criminal charges was made. A warrant was issued to charge Heather Fernandez-Hoefer. She was taken into custody without incident on April 1, 2025.
Update: Arrest Made in Fatal Shooting

Upon arrival, deputies made contact with multiple individuals including juveniles and young adults and located a deceased individual identified as Samuell Tariq Liggins, age 20.
Suspect Arrested in Farmington Murder Case

Following an extensive investigation by Farmington Police Department detectives, an arrest warrant was issued for 40-year-old Matthew Sandoval, who is known to have a family connection to Madrid, who has been charged with 1st Degree Murder and Tampering with Evidence. On March 28, Sandoval was located by U.S. Marshals in the 400 block of W. Animas. Farmington Police officers responded and arrested Sandoval on the outstanding warrant.